The second week of the Elon Musk-OpenAI trial ended with Sam Altman facing a series of damaging witness accounts about how he has run the artificial intelligence company. Musk, the Tesla CEO and one of OpenAI's co-founders, began scoring points against Altman as his legal team called witnesses who raised questions about Altman's honesty, his commitment to AI safety, and his adherence to the nonprofit's mission.
The case is unusual even by the standards of high-stakes tech litigation. Musk alleges that Altman and OpenAI President Greg Brockman "looted" the charity they started together in 2015 by forming a partnership with Microsoft. The trial has become a public examination of OpenAI's transformation from a nonprofit research lab into one of the most valuable and influential AI companies in the world. Jurors are being asked to weigh testimony about governance, safety culture, and whether Altman acted in the interests of the nonprofit he leads.
Key facts from the week
- A former OpenAI safety researcher, Rosie Campbell, testified that she left the company over concerns that its long-term safety work was being eroded as it became more product-focused.
- Tasha McCauley, a former OpenAI board member, said in a deposition that Altman fostered a "culture of lying and culture of deceit" and caused "chaos" and "crisis" at the organization.
- David Schizer, a Columbia Law School professor and nonprofit law expert called by Musk's team, testified that a CEO withholding information from the board is "a big problem" and that the board and CEO must work together to ensure the mission is followed.
The testimony arrived as the trial moves deeper into its second week, with Musk's legal team trying to establish a pattern of conduct that it says shows Altman put growth and corporate partnerships ahead of the charitable mission. Altman has been a central figure in the AI boom, first as president of Y Combinator and later as OpenAI's CEO. His leadership has been both celebrated and contested, especially after OpenAI's board briefly ousted him in November 2023, a decision that triggered a staff revolt and his rapid return.
OpenAI was founded in 2015 as a nonprofit with the stated goal of ensuring that artificial general intelligence benefits all of humanity. Musk was an early backer and board member, but he left the board in 2018. The following year, OpenAI created a capped-profit arm to attract outside investment, and Microsoft eventually committed billions of dollars to the partnership. Those structural changes are at the heart of the case. Musk argues that the arrangement betrayed the nonprofit's founding purpose. The trial is giving jurors a rare look at the internal disputes, safety debates, and governance fights that have shaped OpenAI's rise.
Safety researcher describes erosion of long-term safety teams
Rosie Campbell, a former artificial intelligence safety researcher at OpenAI, testified that she believed the organization was abandoning its commitment to safety during her time there between 2021 and 2024. She described a company that initially had two teams dedicated to long-term AI safety. One team focused on ensuring that AI systems were aligned with human values. The other, which Campbell worked on, was focused on preparing the world for superhuman artificial intelligence.
Over time, Campbell said, OpenAI became more product-focused. Both long-term AI safety teams were eliminated. About half of her team left the company rather than take another job at OpenAI. Her testimony was part of an effort by Musk's lawyers to show that Altman's leadership shifted the organization away from its safety-first roots and toward commercial priorities.
Campbell's account was not a blanket condemnation of OpenAI. She also told the jury that xAI, Musk's artificial intelligence company, likely had an inferior approach to safety than OpenAI. That concession gave her testimony a degree of nuance, even as it supported the broader narrative that OpenAI's safety culture had changed.
When OpenAI's board ousted Altman as CEO, Campbell signed a letter calling for his reinstatement. She told the jury she only did that because she feared that without him, OpenAI employees would end up working at Microsoft, which she believed would be even less likely to be devoted to AI safety. "It was my understanding at the time that the best way for OpenAI to not disintegrate and fall about would be for Sam to return," she said. The remark captured the unusual dynamics of the case: even witnesses who criticized Altman's leadership sometimes saw him as the lesser of available evils.
Ex-board member calls Altman dishonest
A deposition from Tasha McCauley piled onto previous testimony from fellow former OpenAI board member Helen Toner about how little they trusted Altman and the "toxic culture" he presided over. According to McCauley, Altman had caused "chaos" and "crisis" by fostering a "culture of lying and culture of deceit" that had trickled down to other members of OpenAI's leadership.
McCauley testified that Altman had been dishonest about the launch of an artificial intelligence model, GPT4-Turbo. Altman wrongly said that OpenAI's legal department told him that it did not need to be reviewed by an internal safety board before its launch in India, McCauley said. The former board member said Altman's dishonesty had caused "crisis events" every few months. She said she received an email from now-former OpenAI board member Ilya Sutskever that described "dozens of pages of examples of different chaotic events that had occurred from Sam's behavior or lies that he had told."
The testimony from McCauley and Toner is significant because it comes from people who once had direct responsibility for overseeing Altman and the company's mission. Their accounts are intended to show that concerns about Altman's honesty were not isolated complaints from outside critics but were raised inside the boardroom. The jury will have to decide how much weight to give those recollections and whether they support Musk's claims about the nonprofit's governance.
Nonprofit law expert says CEO secrecy is a governance problem
Musk's lawyers then called David Schizer to the stand to talk about nonprofit law. The topic may sound dry, but it is key to the case. Schizer, a professor of law at Columbia Law School, did a good job, with the help of Musk's lawyer, of making it about Altman.
Musk's lawyer, Steven Molo, reviewed a list of Altman's actions, as previously described by witnesses, to determine whether they were consistent with OpenAI's safety-first mission and "nonprofit custom and practice." The answer, almost inevitably, was no. For example, Molo asked Schizer about complaints that OpenAI, under Altman, launched products without the board's knowledge. One question involved complaints that Microsoft tested a version of GPT-4 without first going through the company's safety review process.
"The board and CEO need to be partnering, working together, to make sure the mission is being followed," Schizer said. "If the CEO is withholding that information, it's a big problem," he said. The exchange was designed to give the jury a framework for evaluating the testimony. It suggested that the issue is not merely whether Altman was a good or bad leader in the abstract, but whether he fulfilled the fiduciary and governance obligations that come with running a charitable organization.
Why the testimony matters
The trial is unfolding against the backdrop of a broader debate about how AI companies should be governed. OpenAI's unusual structure, with a nonprofit board overseeing a capped-profit subsidiary, was meant to balance mission and capital. Critics have long argued that the structure created confusion and potential conflicts. The testimony this week focused on whether Altman's actions made the nonprofit's mission secondary to product launches and corporate partnerships.
For the jury, the key question may be credibility. Campbell offered a mixed account, praising some aspects of OpenAI while describing a decline in safety staffing. McCauley and Toner offered sharply critical views of Altman's honesty. Schizer provided an expert perspective on what nonprofit governance requires. Together, the witnesses gave Musk's legal team a set of facts and opinions that could support its argument that Altman and Brockman departed from the charity's purpose.
The defense is likely to challenge the witnesses' interpretations and to argue that OpenAI's structure and partnerships were necessary to pursue its mission at scale. The jury will also have to consider the context of a fast-moving industry in which safety practices, product timelines, and board oversight are often contested. The trial is expected to continue with more testimony, and the jury's eventual decision will depend on how it weighs the competing accounts of Altman's leadership.
Schizer's testimony ended on a pointed note about the relationship between a nonprofit's board and its chief executive. "The board and CEO need to be partnering, working together, to make sure the mission is being followed," he said. "If the CEO is withholding that information, it's a big problem." The statement left jurors with a clear standard to apply as they consider the evidence about Altman's conduct.
Source: MSN News